Reporting on Disasters: An Art Form or Dangerous Game?
Time for a light hearted post. (at least for my standards, especially during these past few weeks.) As many know, I am an early riser, and do my best work in the wee hours of the morning.
Over these past few days, I have watched various reporters from CNN, ABC, NBC, CBS and other channels going down to Florida to report on hurricane Dennis. Equipped with microphone in hand, and wearing the post up to the date rain gear, these journalists, are speaking as the winds begin to hurl, street signs blow away, and roofs of other people's homes are ripped from the rooftops, causing destruction and devastation. Winds are hurling and whirling, like spinning dervishes, at hundreds of miles per hour. Meanwhile, the journalists, are telling the world about the dangers of the hurricane, the destruction that is being caused, and how it is not a good idea to be outside.
This type of reporting has also been seen in the face of the coverage of the tsunami in So. East Asia, or following a police chase down the streets of Los Angeles.
Here is the question of the day: Is this responsible journalism, or are journalists contributing to the problem and making the wrong type of statement by putting themselves in harm's way?
Thank you for your minds.
Over these past few days, I have watched various reporters from CNN, ABC, NBC, CBS and other channels going down to Florida to report on hurricane Dennis. Equipped with microphone in hand, and wearing the post up to the date rain gear, these journalists, are speaking as the winds begin to hurl, street signs blow away, and roofs of other people's homes are ripped from the rooftops, causing destruction and devastation. Winds are hurling and whirling, like spinning dervishes, at hundreds of miles per hour. Meanwhile, the journalists, are telling the world about the dangers of the hurricane, the destruction that is being caused, and how it is not a good idea to be outside.
This type of reporting has also been seen in the face of the coverage of the tsunami in So. East Asia, or following a police chase down the streets of Los Angeles.
Here is the question of the day: Is this responsible journalism, or are journalists contributing to the problem and making the wrong type of statement by putting themselves in harm's way?
Thank you for your minds.

16 Comments:
My vote: definately contributing to the problem.
As I said in my blog (forgive me quoting, but it's easier to just repeat this):
I was just commenting on how this hurricane must have been such a great disappointment to our local news crews. No one had the chance to go to the beach and stand there, fighting the wind and the rain, to tell us that the hurricane was coming. They love doing that! The dialogue is always like this:
Sue: Well, Fred, it sure looks gusty out there. Time to hunker down*!
Fred: Yes, Sue, it certainly is. I've just seen 3 dogs and a lamppost blow by. Oh! There goes a mail truck. I tell you, it's dangerous out here. Good thing that almost everyone has evacuated by now...
(Which always begs the question: Well then what are YOU doing there??? It's not like you can get an interview with the Hurricane or anything...)
(*hunker down - worn out catch phrase that worn out reporters and TV anchors use. )
--------------
After a while, you can say all their lines for them. If they're so desperate for news, let them go interview the idiots that always stay behind. Perhaps then they'll convince people to leave once they see those drivelling idiots.
Further to that, I wonder how many of these reporters would love to OBJECT to being out in these dangerous situations but either are rebuffed by management or don't vocalize their (valid) concerns for fear of recrimination?
I have a difficult time watching footage such as that just because the people who are there in harm's way KNOW how bad it is, and these journalists' lives are not worth my (or anyone's) curiousity to see just how terrible it is.
There is probably more to add as I mull over the question, but those are my initial thoughts.
If they get hit in the head by a flying object, they have no one to blame but themselves. And their idoit bosses who inform them they must stand out there and get hit in the head by a flying object.
Yeah, I tend to think they're contributing to the problem. Just think what a powerful statement it would be if they reported on it from the studio... then people might actually be (appropriately) afraid.
WE'RE DOOMED! They LOVE to shout it out. Let's face it, they love bad weather. They love bad news. It's so annoying, and it's dangerous. They contribute to the problem.
Ohhhhh, television news is always so bogus.
Look at how many fires they cover only because they have an expensive helicopter that get them pictures for the local newscast....
I think you're right about them sending the wrong message when they are standing under a Ramada Hotel sign that it perilously close to spinning off it's signpost and decapitationg the cameraperson!
Cheers,
Mr. H.K.
Postcards from Hell's Kitchen
And I Quote Blog
American news is so sensationalized. The fires, the whizzing bullets, and, of course, taunting mother nature on one of her bad days.
Now not that I'm defending stupidity here, but there is a reason why they do it. It keeps people glued to the TV. Trust me when the news reports are all about how identically hot everyone is all over the country you'll probably change the chanel as soon as you find out whether it's going to rain tomorrow.
"It's hot in Osaka today." "Yes, hot isn't it." "Hmmm, yes hot." "And in Fukuoka it's also very hot." "It's so hot" (repeat until every old woman in every major city has declared it hot)
My recommendation, turn off the TV and get your news somewhere else.
Those dardevil reporters are nuts! I saw that guy on CNN with a sign blowing to bits near him, and he sounded like an excited kid. It made for an exciting report though, but I guess it makes others want to join in on the thrill of danger. It looked fun!
Barbara -
I'm sorry a group of malcontented holier than thou have caused you to question your beliefs and feelings towards Judaism. Realize that they can only destroy you if you let them; also this is a very closed and narrow world that will only accept their own view because to question would lead to other questions that no one wants to deal with.It's better to keep the masses ignorant than to allow them to question. This still doesn't excuse their behavior! Many are very afraid of change and when challenged become vitiolic and hateful. I'm truly sorry that you have been on the recieving end of their nastinesss. It was uncalled for and totally unneccassary but understand when an animal is caged and feels as if it is being attacked it comes out fighting and clawing. You probably struck a whole host of raw nerves.
I hope you receive this post as I was unable to post on your last blog. Please don't let these "people" and I use the term very loosly, make you loose/leave your faith. As you've said there are too few of us! What they seem to forget is that when the nazis came for us - they didn't ask about our level of observance.
If you're dissatisfied with Chabad that's one thing but don't cut yourself off from them because of the others nastiness (remember- your mother's saying don't cut off your nose to spite your face). If something in Chabad speaks to you then go for it! (I'm not from chabad - so don't think that's why I say this). I just know of their work.
Please Don't leave Judaism because of this - that will give them the ultimate power - something they don't deserve!!!!!!
I wish there was a way I could help you through your pain and help you understand that not everyone is like that. Many of us are accepting of all jews. We don't differentiate - just be the best you can be (now I sound like the army slogan - sorry!) and do what is comfortable for you. Please don't apologize- no one has the right to make you feel abused!!!
I wish you all the very best and hope you find the peace you are searching for. May you find the answers you're looking for and I hope they will allow you to feel comfortable as a jew once again.
It is retarded to report during a hurricane. There is simply NO reason to be outside near the beach as a category 3 strom rolls in.
But, it is not me so I say let them report.
And while I am at it, I want to add one more thing. If a hurricane destroies my house, I *WILL* shoot at anyone who comes by and photographs me or my stuff. If you are going to come to a ravaged area to help (and many people do) then I will take whatever you are offering that I need and say thank you. But if you are just here to be a lookie-loo and get in the way of people trying to help, I will shoot.
And I am a good shot. I have several rifles.
I agree with actonbell. They can't wait to get out there and be as dramatic as possible in the name of "reporting news." It's bogus. I too watched that stupid report on the sign falling near to the reporter. So a sign fell. You went there in HOPES that things would blow past you. Get over yourself and quit acting like it was the end of the earth. Cripes, we had a windstorm that took out two mailboxes on our street some years ago. It wasn't a hurricane, it wasn't a tornado, it was flipping WIND. It was nature. It happens. It's going to KEEP happening. It's not the end of the world and I'm so sick of these folks trying to make it sound like total devastation just because some shingles are flying down the street.
Sorry... had to get that off my chest.
On the flipside, journalism is also a business and it's not going away. Journalists are put in place to get ratings... to a certain degree, they are coached to be as dramatic as possible without looking ridiculous. They're earning their keep. Some are just worse at it than others. Kind of like the way it is in any business.
how are they any different from bloggers who only want to show their pov by replicating previous comments on other blogs and not showing the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth. barbie you are just as bad as they are.
barbara - i haven't been following all your discussions on judaism and your own faith, but i'm sorry you are feeling the way you do and look forward to your return to the bloggosphere because, rather selfishly, it's a blog i enjoy looking in on each day - UC x
I was watching the Weather Channel in an attempt to find out whether the hurricane would be bringing any storms to Houston. I had to watch almost a half hour of silly reporters dodging debris and telling people to get off the streets before I even got a good look at a satellite image. Crazy sensationalism and definitely more problem than solution.
Barbara, your comments link for today (Tuesday) is not enabled.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home