Wednesday, November 23, 2005

Speaking Up or Staying Silent: When Do Our Words Matter?

It is no mystery, that I am a strong, opinionated woman. Sometimes, when I speak, it is better if I stay silent, and other times, I am silent, when I should speak up. Ultimately, we all know our own level of tolerance, and what is important to speak up about and what is not. On a personal note, I try to stay as still as a log if someone is attacking me personally, and anger surfaces. What usually happens, is that I am at the loosing end always, since more discomfort arises when I say something that is best left unsaid.

Yesterday, however, I saw something on television while I was exercising on the tred-mill. As many of you know from my past posts, I am a strong advocate for the mentally ill. On this station, a major network was advertising an episode called Supernatural: The Insane asylum. As part of the promotion, the crew were wearing straight jackets, drooling, and acting in a very unflattering way, using words like 'nuts' and 'crazy' as well. I sent an email to the station informing them how there was nothing funny nor amusing about someone who had to be restrained against his/her will, and that this segment was mean-spirited and insensitive. I let it be. Immediately, the head of the station, a Mr. Rubin, sent me a letter of apology, and explanation and acknowledged that this segment was indeed in poor taste. I sent him a letter thanking him and indicated that if he was willing to do a segment on heightening people's awareness of mental illness, I would be happy to participate. We will see what happens.

Today, I feel good. I was able to go outside of myself and fight for a cause and against a stigma that I am passionate about. To change the view or opinions of one is, in Judaism, like changing the world.

Wishing everyone and their families a Happy and peaceful holiday.

Thank you for your minds.

26 Comments:

Blogger Y.Y. said...

supernatural i love that show!! on the WB
i cant believe that he cared about what you had to say.
tred_mill? whats that? lol

10:32 AM  
Blogger Niobium said...

"Speak even if your voice shakes" is one of my favorite quotes. And my voice shakes all the time.

10:36 AM  
Blogger BarbaraFromCalifornia said...

YY,

Now I know why you have not heard of Elie Wiesel!

Yes, it is nice that he cared enough to respond. A tred-mill is a piece of exercise equipment, for running. I work out every day.

Niobium, I like that quote!

10:52 AM  
Blogger Meegan said...

Barbara,

Good for you for standing up for what you believe in and for taking the time to voice your opinion. Not enough people do.

Have a wonderful Thanksgiving, and I send my best to you and all your family, especially your daughter.

xo,
Meegan

12:00 PM  
Blogger mysickmind said...

i usually speak my mind no matter what the situation, even if it gets me in trouble

the only time i hold my tongue is when i'm confronted with an idiot or a closed minded person, with either one the result is the same... frustration

1:32 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

i think that was fantastic what you did! great for you! after reading your post, i don't know if i would have done that -- i know i would have wanted to, but that's just not the same.

i've learned to just be quiet when others are ignorant and going off -- think experience has trained me to think that i can't change people who are like that -- in return they usually think that i'm stupid (inside i'm thinking that i can't be bothered arguing with idiots). i think i reserve my true feelings for those i can trust and don't openly offer -- unless really motivated or pushed -- right or wrong.

this is a topic i'll have to think more about how i deal with things.

by the way, wishing you a wonderful and peaceful thanksgiving --

2:37 PM  
Blogger concerned citizen said...

as the mother of a daughter who is 'misunderstood' I agree that mental-illness is no laffing matter. the mentally ill do not choose to be that way. Life is very hard for them. They are fortunate if they have someone to love them unconditionally. My daughter frenquently disrupts our family & trys our patience, but we can't imagine throwing her out in the cold. I have had to fiercely protect her, her whole life.
You have a nice blog. I will be back.

3:12 PM  
Blogger concerned citizen said...

P.S. I loved, 'Franz Kafka, The Trial.'

3:14 PM  
Blogger Trudging said...

Mental Illness is very hard.

6:56 PM  
Blogger concerned citizen said...

Those who write about life, reflect about life. You see in others who you are.
BERNARD MALAMUD

Benard Malamud taught at OSC in my state of Oregon.

7:18 PM  
Blogger concerned citizen said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

7:19 PM  
Blogger Assorted Babble by Suzie said...

Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family....wishing the best.

God Bless....

8:33 PM  
Blogger Linda Jones Malonson said...

Bravo Barbara!
It only takes one voice to begin a chain reaction that can rock the world ... especially when the voice is dealing with truth ... that's my personal thought.

I am so very proud of you. Next time you have to voice an opinion like this, share the email address with the rest of us and we will fight right beside you. You don't have to stand along in this fight.

Peace and blessing to you and your love ones.

8:49 PM  
Blogger Stacey said...

Good for you to speak out about something so important! Way to go, Barbara.

Have a peaceful, wonderful Thanksgiving.

9:42 PM  
Blogger Nerdine said...

I am so impressed with what you did. I would probably react, but not think of acting on it.
My mum works in psychiatry here, and I grew up to know a lot of wonderful people with different problems. I think my mum has the best attitude to it - just show them you care. Love them, - it certainly has changed many of them - they're not used to "official" people loving them and caring for them - as horrible that sounds...
Thanks for speaking your mind in such an important matter.

Guro

12:25 AM  
Blogger GodlessMom said...

Good for you! I'm glad to hear that Mr. Rubin responded in such a positive way to your email. Sometimes little things like that can start the ball rolling toward big improvements.

I hope your holiday is a good one.

4:58 AM  
Blogger Eitan Ha'ahzari said...

Barbara and all other Jewish/Israeli bloggers out there: You've been tagged(by yours trully)

Here's the question: who would you vote for in the upcoming elections and why?

Be'tikva, Eitan.

6:19 AM  
Blogger Lila said...

That mental illness segment sounds terrible. Ick.

I hope you have a joyful Thanksgiving, Barbara.

9:10 AM  
Blogger BarbaraFromCalifornia said...

Thank you all. I just did something stupid, and should have followed my own advice and stayed silent.

10:06 AM  
Blogger mal said...

WOW....some one actually listens in corporate America? Nicely handled

10:10 AM  
Blogger Fred said...

Well done. And, the fact that you got such a quick reply is awesome.

Happy Thanksgiving - I hope you and your family enjoys the day.

10:33 AM  
Blogger Pragmatician said...

I admire what you did, when I face something like that I just grumble and wish they will loose all their viewers or something like that. At least you did somethign concrete!

10:42 AM  
Blogger sirbarrett said...

Happy belated Thanksgiving. The world may be a muddle, but one thing that cannot be taken away is new hope. Our most valuable tool is our minds, so I'm glad you advocate their health, and a sober representation of our mental states even when they are not. It is mindful of you to speak your mind about the stations actions directly to them. You connected your voice. They obviously thought of it in a new light.

Thank you for your mind

9:23 PM  
Blogger Turtleheart said...

Barbara-

I think its great you made that call. This world needs more people who will stand up and say something the way you did.

Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours!

11:42 PM  
Blogger I'm not even supposed to be here today said...

Dear Barbara, I wanted to comment on the post from today 11/25... I feel bad that you are being harrassed by someone you've never met, for reasons that don't seem to make any sense to rational thoughtful people. I hope this person loses interest and moves on quickly. Until then, keep your chin up and try to ignore the person. I think the advice we give our kids about dealing with ignorance, bullies, etc. is probably the best solution.

Keep Smiling... I'm thinking about you!

9:31 AM  
Blogger Sum Kinda Princess said...

I come from a long line of "misunderstood" people. It's nice to see others out there that are sensitive to the mental illnesses that plague the innocent. You're a very strong woman, and that's fabulous

9:00 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home