Do You Ever Ask Why Me?
Surely many of you, when thrust inside of a situation that is difficult or painful might ask the question, 'why me?' Some of us, myself included, learn to step backwards, often getting sideswiped in the process, to see if there is anything that we could have, would have or should have done differently to prevent something from happening the way it did. If we only had one of those all powerful magic wands, imagine how it would all turn out! Or, as the old song from the Rolling Stones, goes, Time is on My Side.
Trying to make sense of everything that has been happening this year, the death of my father, the illness of my daughter, has left me in a fragile and exposed state. No matter what efforts or attempts we employ to make sense of these events in our lives, if we allow our eyes to remain open and our ears to hear, we can learn something. Even if the lesson is not to our liking, or speaksof learning to live with un-resolved issues, these are messages to hear. It may not be what we like, but nevertheless, we learn. There may be a need to reach out to others, just to hear the words, 'we care', rather than to retell the story, open up the wounds, make the pain grow bigger and bigger. I know for me, at this moment in time, I want people to be there for me, but it is too difficult to talk, to answer questions or speak about what is happening around me.
This remarkable book by Joan Didion, The Year of Magical Thinking, begins with a quote: "Life changes fast. Life changes in the instant. You sit down to dinner and life as you know it ends."
What a powerful message exists in these words, and reading this book, about her own personal issues of death and loss, has made me know that isolation is not the answer at all. Everything unfolds in its own time. Didion tackled these questions as she took stock of many important moments that lead to the illness of her daughter and the death of her husband, and found some personal, and often painful resolution. Nevertheless, this is a remarkable and honest book about love, loss, illness and grief.
Here is what I know, when I ask, why me? I have no power to change the direction nor course of events as I want them to be. We may think that we have been lucky or unlucky during our lives, but in truth, luck has very little to do with life. All I can do is my part, whether that is to cry in a moment, go visit someone, bring items, show love and support, or go to the cemetery. Bad things happen to everyone, at any given time, regardless of luck in life. Self-pity is not helpful for any length of time. Actually, it makes me feel as if I am entitled to something, when in reality, that is simply not the case at all. How we deal with our misfortunes, and what we learn from them, may or may not make our lives better, richer or fuller. But they will in some way or another effect us and who we are as well as who we become. For me, writing does help sort out the emotions as I see them blazing on the screen in black and white. And the support from those who read my blog means so very much to me, an unexpected bonus, for which I am most greatful.
Thank you for your minds.
Trying to make sense of everything that has been happening this year, the death of my father, the illness of my daughter, has left me in a fragile and exposed state. No matter what efforts or attempts we employ to make sense of these events in our lives, if we allow our eyes to remain open and our ears to hear, we can learn something. Even if the lesson is not to our liking, or speaksof learning to live with un-resolved issues, these are messages to hear. It may not be what we like, but nevertheless, we learn. There may be a need to reach out to others, just to hear the words, 'we care', rather than to retell the story, open up the wounds, make the pain grow bigger and bigger. I know for me, at this moment in time, I want people to be there for me, but it is too difficult to talk, to answer questions or speak about what is happening around me.
This remarkable book by Joan Didion, The Year of Magical Thinking, begins with a quote: "Life changes fast. Life changes in the instant. You sit down to dinner and life as you know it ends."
What a powerful message exists in these words, and reading this book, about her own personal issues of death and loss, has made me know that isolation is not the answer at all. Everything unfolds in its own time. Didion tackled these questions as she took stock of many important moments that lead to the illness of her daughter and the death of her husband, and found some personal, and often painful resolution. Nevertheless, this is a remarkable and honest book about love, loss, illness and grief.
Here is what I know, when I ask, why me? I have no power to change the direction nor course of events as I want them to be. We may think that we have been lucky or unlucky during our lives, but in truth, luck has very little to do with life. All I can do is my part, whether that is to cry in a moment, go visit someone, bring items, show love and support, or go to the cemetery. Bad things happen to everyone, at any given time, regardless of luck in life. Self-pity is not helpful for any length of time. Actually, it makes me feel as if I am entitled to something, when in reality, that is simply not the case at all. How we deal with our misfortunes, and what we learn from them, may or may not make our lives better, richer or fuller. But they will in some way or another effect us and who we are as well as who we become. For me, writing does help sort out the emotions as I see them blazing on the screen in black and white. And the support from those who read my blog means so very much to me, an unexpected bonus, for which I am most greatful.
Thank you for your minds.

24 Comments:
I believe we are sent to Earth to learn what we cannot in the perfection of the presence of God. What we learn in part is up to God, but it's also up to our own design. There are times we learn when things are going well, but think of what we learn when things are difficult. Having free will on Earth is the center of knowledge and therefore of faith.
One of the hardest lessons to learn is to not isolate yourself in the midst of difficulty.
I'm sorry you're having a tough year, Barbara. Thank you for this thoughtful blog entry... lots to think about.
This post reminded me of the I CHING reading that I recieved when asking the question recently: 'Why me?'
It is called, LEE, or Fire on Fire as Hexagram 30. There is a section that pertains to the 3rd Line of the Hexagram. It reads, "The setting Sun, the old man should beat on his pot, but instead he worries about Death"
Commentary: The afternoon sun it brings thoughts of mortality and consequent melancholy. When the great man's wife died, his friends came to visit and Mourn with him. They found him sitting in front of his home, beating on a wine jug and singing. They were shocked. The great old man replied, " "My wife has entered the realm of Eternity. I sit and beat my pot and sing. What harm is there in that?""
So, should we ask,,, why not me?
And beating a pot and singing is so much more fun than the melancholy.... but regardless,, I empathize and hope BOTH of Our Spirits RISE UP and become Joyful again.. but offer a shoulder to cry on ,,an ear to listen,, if you want, as I know you would do the same.
I'm sorry it's such a tough year for you. I've had years like that. I've been fortunate to have avoided that sort of misfortune for a long time, but troubles always come and go. One just hopes they don't all come at once.
However, I've had years where I thought I couldn't bend anymore, and that I would finally break. But, I found to my amazement that I was much more elastic than I thought. I grew in confidence and my coping skills improved. And sometimes misfortunes led to better opportunities that I wouldn't have had otherwise.
Hang in there.
As many of you know, I have ADD. Having ADD and being a full time college student do not make for a symbiotic relationship. As I struggle with--and attempt to cope with--these issues I often ask myself why me.
Why can't I do well in school?
Why can't I be "normal"?
Why can't I succeed?
I try not to think this way. However, when an inability to comprehend basic ideas bring me to my knees, I wonder why me?
What I've learned to ask is: Why not me?
Sorry for your troubles. Wish I had words of wisdom, but I don't.
Barbara, When I start to feel down and ask myself "Why Me?", I turn it around and ask "Why not me?" Who am I that I should not have trouble or problems? Am I better than anyone else? It puts things into perspective and I stop asking.
I am a person who needs someone to talk to when things are down. I share and talk things thru. My husband tends to withdraw and work things out withing his own head.
I didn't know that your dad had died this year. It is hard to have so much to deal with so close together. Just remember we are here for you. Love ya.
Nothing clever or particularly comforting to say here, but know you are in my thoughts. I wish I had some magic words. But you are cared about.
Yes I've asked Why Me?....a few times....can't help it....But I also think in the back of my mind...someone else has it worse...This was a great heartfelt post Barb....You do make people stop and think....Thanks!!!
Cheers to better days!!!
Thanks for stopping by my blog, Barbara. This is my first visit at yours.
I am very sorry to learn of your difficult time. I wish you much strength at this time in dealing with all of it.
I just read a review of this very book. It sounded so insightful and moving. It is on my list to read.
Thank you all for your kind, thoughtful and heartfelt words. I am truly, truly greatful with my heart.
Just writing about how I feel helps me quite a bit, and believe it or not, I was able to sleep a bit more peaceful last night as a result.
Thinking too much can definitely be a problem, not a solution to one's problems. That is why writing, turning it over, and letting it go, with prayer, helps.
I feel truly honored to have found so many thoughtful, loving people in blogsville.
Today, I attend a legal seminar for half a day.
Have a good day to all. Thank you again.
Barbara, I want to add my love and good thoughts. I'm so sorry you are having so many problems so close together. When it rains it pours, doesn't it?
I don't think I've ever asked "Why me?" because my sister has a severe disability that causes her tremendous physical pain every day of her life. I grew up seeing her suffering and wondering "Why her?" I still wonder that at times.
I don't know. But I do believe God does, and I hope when we die we will get to find out.
One day at a time Barbara. It is OK to not want to talk to people about things right now. Everyone has to deal with things the best way they know how. Sometimes clarity is hard to find and speaking to lots of people and hearing their opinions and thoughts can cloud the mind even more making clarity even harder to obtain.
Some people need to talk, some people do not. In time you will want to talk, and your loved ones (friends and family) will be there for you. When you feel like it.
Much love sent to you during a difficult time.
When words fail
and good thoughts count
know that you
and your love ones
are in my thoughts
in my prayers
daily ...
Sounds like a powerful read.
Thanks for the recent compliments... No jokes to share though... Actually I HATE jokes believe it or not... Jokes are one thing, humor is another...
Meanwhile have a good shabbat!
This has been a rough year for you. *hugs*
I never ask "Why me?" but I do ask "Why anyone?" The things that have pained me the most, I wouldn't wish on any living being. But life isn't fair; it deals out tragedy with a terrifying randomness. You never know when it's going to hit you. All you can do is be grateful for what you DO have.
However, it's normal, human, and, I think, healthy to wallow a bit when things get rough. It's okay to bitch and moan (when problems are minor) and cry out for help or withdraw (when they're more major). Whatever it takes. Nobody has a right to tell you how to handle your own fear or grief. To tell someone that they "should" adopt a new attitude or "should" behave a certain way in the face of distress is bizarre and invalidating.
I can't imagine judging you for how you're handling your recent stresses. I don't walk in your shoes. All I can do is say I'm touched by your pain and praying that things will be better for you.
Here's hoping today was a better day...
Reading all of these wonderful comments touches my heart, and I thank you all for each and every one of them.
These past few weeks have been a time of desparing emotional ups and downs. It is my fervent hope that ultmately, I will gain some new insight into life, and develop the strength to keep focused and stay positive, which is my usual state of being.
Elizabeth Edwards said something once that has stayed with me for a long time. As you know, she lost a son who was 16 years old very suddenly. She was devistated. Two years ago, she was diagnosed with cancer. She said, with her own situation, she has choices available to her. She can find doctors, read, gather information, and make decisions. With her son, the choices were taken from her. So long as one can breathe, there is hope and from hope comes everything.
Hi B,
Just wanted to share one more thing to clarify my position on letting yourself wallow as needed. When I was 15, two of my friends died in a freak carbon monoxide poisoning accident. Kristen and Jennifer were best friends so their families held joint viewings and funerals. The girls were laid out in separate rooms. Kristen's room was packed whereas Jennifer's room was almost empty. Kristen's very religious family took the approach that while they were devastated, they believed this was God's will and were glad their daughter was in heaven. They were grateful for the time they had with her. They were hugging and offering support to their grieving guests. Jennifer's family, in contrast, was bitter. They were angry and falling apart. Naturally everyone wanted to be around Kristen's family.
Three years later, Kristen's parents had divorced in the midst of their lawsuit against Jennifer's family (the accident took place at Jennifer's home). Kristen's mother was diagnosed with terminal cancer and ended up dying a few months later. Jennifer's family, in contrast, was intact.
I saw this as a lesson in the value of emotional authenticity. Clearly Kristen's parents were ripped apart by her death, but their reluctance to let it show in favor of walking around with a perpetual air of gratitude ended up tearing them apart. Sure, it made them popular in the months following Kristen's death, but did they really have an obligation to make others comfortable with the death of their daughter? The stress of dealing with unacknowledged emotions coupled with the obligation to avoid making their friends too uncomfortable destroyed them. They walked around exchanging platitudes. But platitudes don't do squat when the loss is that great. Jennifer's family, on the other hand, were no fun to be around. The death of a child is ugly. But owning their feelings about it was, I believe, what enabled them to remain intact.
All of those platitudes -- this is God's (or whoever's) will, so-and-so's suffering is over, we're grateful for the time we had with her, there are people with far greater losses than ours -- are true. But forcing yourself to adopt them before you truly feel them is emotionally inauthentic. It's this forced inauthenticity that does harm. So -- long story short -- my view is, wallow as needed.
Barbara,
It is clear that you are dealing with an emotional time and it does help to be able to openly let your feelings express themselves.
I had a daughter who was killed in a drunk driver car wreck...she was only eleven. I was in the hospital from Spring of that year until the Fall season and had numerous surgeries.
My bones healed long, long before I was able to cope with my loss.
I feel now that if I had of had the ability to speak out to friends and had their support I would have been on the road to recovery much sooner.
Feel the energy of friendly communication and lean on it.
Bless you!
I don't have any particular insight other than to suggest that you keep blogging, the release should be helpful.
I won't try to imagine what you've been going through all year, but I will say as many others have ... keep writing, talking, communicating. It's hard to believe these can be healing (though they can), so try to think of these activities as release. We all need release and unless we go after it, it's just not going to come knocking at our door.
Thank you for this thought provoking post. I've asked "why me" on several occasions in my lifetime. I'll probably ask it again sometime. I think it's human nature.
But the important thing is, everything we go through builds character and puts yet another rung on the ladder that will carry us to personal freedom.
I admire you, Barbara, for posting during difficult times. You do a wonderful job of it too.
Barbara -- I have been AWOL for so long and am only logging in to blogs for the first time in over six weeks. (I didn't even realize it had been so long until I looked at my own blog and saw the date of my last post!) But I am scanning through your posts and see that your daughter has been ill...that you have been having a rough time. I am so, so sorry that I have not been around to at least offer a word of support. Not that my verbal addition lessens your pain or bolsters you, but because I think it is important to at least add a voice to those who support you...who grieve and worry with you. To remind you that you are not alone. We are just cyber-friends, but perhaps the connection you experience here on the blog is duplicated with your personal friendships, and this is a reminder that while we walk through some experiences alone, there are others standing on the sidelines to encourage us along the way. No one can step inside your pain and share the load or take part of your burden and carry it for you. No matter how hard we wish it were true or try to be in step with you, your experience dealing with your daughter's illness is your experience alone. I know in my trials these past few months, it has been a very, very lonely walk at times. I have taken heart though that I have friends around me who are just 'there.' They don't try to make it better...they don't try to explain it away...they are just 'there' so that I know they are with me to the extent they can be. They have walked their own lonely roads with other difficult situations, so while the circumstances are singular, the experience and point of reference is shared. We are together in our knowledge of aloneness.
Gosh, that sounds like a bunch of babble, but mainly I just wanted you to know that my silence was not because I knew of your pain and didn't care...it was because I simply have not been around. You can always call me if you want to talk. I understand aloneness and feeling as though no one else could possibly understand where I am.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home