Is There Always A Lesson That Exists in Everything We Experience?
First of all, I want to share that my daughter is starting to show good improvement now, and God willing, she will continue in this direction and be released from the hospital soon.
It is often said that a lesson exists in everything we experience. Sometimes, death happens unexpectedly, natural disasters occur and take many lives, unexpected illness appears out of nowhere, we keep making the same mistakes over and over again, and continue. Often there are no adequate answers to why these events occur. More often than not, we hear it said that there is a lesson that exists in everything we experience. Sometimes we hear, we are exactly where we are supposed to be, in the right place at the right time. God does not give us more than we can handle. But is it always a good lesson that we experience?
For example, as a Jew, I cannot understand there being anything good about losing 6 million Jews who were brutally murdered during the Holocaust. It is equally difficult for me to understand why children are born with severe birth defects, such as down-syndrome, or serious mental illnesses such as bi-polar disorders, or schizophrenia. I cannot understand how young people, in the prime of their lives, are killed in car accidents. What are the lessons to be learned there?
Here is the question of the day: Is there a lesson that exists in everything we experience? Is it always a good one? If not, I do you reconcile it with your faith, and belief that this is what God has in store of us as individual's or as a group of people?
It is often said that a lesson exists in everything we experience. Sometimes, death happens unexpectedly, natural disasters occur and take many lives, unexpected illness appears out of nowhere, we keep making the same mistakes over and over again, and continue. Often there are no adequate answers to why these events occur. More often than not, we hear it said that there is a lesson that exists in everything we experience. Sometimes we hear, we are exactly where we are supposed to be, in the right place at the right time. God does not give us more than we can handle. But is it always a good lesson that we experience?
For example, as a Jew, I cannot understand there being anything good about losing 6 million Jews who were brutally murdered during the Holocaust. It is equally difficult for me to understand why children are born with severe birth defects, such as down-syndrome, or serious mental illnesses such as bi-polar disorders, or schizophrenia. I cannot understand how young people, in the prime of their lives, are killed in car accidents. What are the lessons to be learned there?
Here is the question of the day: Is there a lesson that exists in everything we experience? Is it always a good one? If not, I do you reconcile it with your faith, and belief that this is what God has in store of us as individual's or as a group of people?

29 Comments:
I believe that everything we go through in life is a learning experience, positive or negative. Of course it is all part of G-ds master plan and we have to believe it, know it, accept it.
Barbara, I believe that everyone is delt his "own deck of cards", it is up to us to live and learn from the cards we are delt. I do believe that there are lessons in everything we do. If you touch a hot stove and don't move your hand, you will get burned. We all learn in this fashion.
There are many times that we don't understand why we have to experience certain things, but the Lord knows what we need. We must trust in him and learn from our experiences. Thanks for the post. Glad your daughter is doing better.
Yes, there are personal tragedies, and there are tragedies of larger proportion. These are distinguishable.
I cannot understand how it is part of God's master plan to have 6 million of His chosen people to be killed. It is difficult to grasp how 250,000 people died last December in the Tsunami, or 50,000 this year in the earthquake in Pakastian.
Just food for thought.
leesons can be learned with any experience if you accept the fact that god is behind all
one lesson about sudden death can be that noone should feel secure about themself that brings ignorance everyone should keep in mind that tommorow maybe i am gone that thought keeps a person humble
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
barb
do you understand why only 20% of jews went on to be freed from the egyption exile the rest died during the days of darkness
The lessons I take from premature death is to try to live my life in a way that I won't fear death. Death is not terrifying to those that have nothing to be afraid of, to those with a clear concience.
Viewed from a human, selfish perspective death, especially premature death seems unfair.
D
David, your approach is from the perspective of the self. What about looking at something bigger, like the Holocaust, or the pograms?
YY, even if God is behind everything, this is a conclusion without explanation.
I think frumgirl has a good point and one echoed by one of my favorite plays, THE TRIAL OF GOD by Holocaust survivor, Elie Weisel. With everything going on in the world this year, 2005, and to me personaly, I re-read this play yesterday.
In this play, it is the holiday of Purim, and a Purim play is being presented. During the play, an entire village of Jews are killed, and only two Jews survive. These actors stage a mock trial and put God on trial, indicting Him for allowing such horrible things to happen to His people. There is only one defended of God, who is present, a tzaddik, a Rabbi. In the end, it is concluded that faith in God must be boundless as God is himself. If it exists at the expense of peple, too bad. God is eternal, man is not.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
IMHO, everything we experience has the potential for a learning experience.
I think the mistake is for us try and qualify them as good or bad. I think they just "are". It is how we choose to use or not use what we learn that constitutes good or evil and whether the lesson is good or bad.
The fact that a lesson is painful, unpleasant or heart wrenching does not decrease its value, it just increases its cost
i don't know if everything that happens is meant to learn a lesson from. i do think that if you believe life is being played out in a "fate"-way and things happen so that future events will happen -- then there is a purpose to it nonetheless. in everything we can learn something from and turn it into a positive learning experience, i think. (i probably could have worded this better, but i'm having one of those days where the words aren't quite coming out like i want them to).
The Piesetzner Rebbe who was killed in the Warsaw Ghetto had his writing from the war years discovered in the 1950s in the rubble and it is fascinating. In Kabbalistic writings we find the idea that as long as the world is in imperfect God suffers..and his suffering manifests itself in this world.
At the end..after trying to make sense of the madness around him, he concludes (this is after his whole family was killed already) I don't know what's going but if this is what we're going through..I can only imagine the pain God is going through..and my heart is filled with joy that God has given me the privelege to share in his pain!
Deep stuff..
D
I don't know if everything is a lesson, some suffering in this world is unexplainable.
It's simply beyond our comprehension.
It certainly a good thing to look for a lesson in events, but I don't know if life is one long lesson it's perhaps also a movie and in like one there's nothing we can do but watch.
Not thinking like most, I believe that everything is made by our 'collective' minds working with the material world. It is so easy, I think for us to blame the devil, praise god for the bad and good of our lives, yet we don't recognize our part in it most of the time. I think we do create our own reality, from a 'higher self' point of view, that gives us the freedom of will to see either a positive or negative. If we latch onto the negative, and imbue an event with 'evil' then Evil appears in its myriad forms to take over the course of the event. But if we allow for the event to be Blessed/Good then the Benign forces show themselves and lead the way. It really is our choice, to see the world as Living and vibrant or cast it as malignant and impersonal. The outcome follows our mindset, so each of us really are the Responsible ones regarding the Good and Evil evident in the world, we have made it this way from day one. I do believe that is the story given by your religion, Barbara in the garden of Eden. To have Knowledge of Good and Evil was the 'gift' of the fruit from that Tree. We choose the flavor of the fruit in my opinion. So yes there is always a lesson, which flavor will we choose.
Mallory - I really like the point you have made about the cost of a lesson being increased and/or decreased.
elisa- yes, it does sort of also involve the question of free will v. fate.
David - I have heard of this story that you are telling, and it is very deep, as is the Kabbalah, which I am told one is not to study until he/she reaches the age of 40.
juditt - welcome to my site, and thank you so much for that enlightening article. The point being made by the last story dove-tails on that made by Elie Weisel in a way. We just keep praying, when faced with adversity or celebration.
prag-I cannot and will not even understand the suffering that 6 million Jews, and those were just the ones murdered, along with those who survived.
scott - good point. The blame game does come into play more often than not as an explanation.
More and more I believe that things in life just happen according to Nature. I don't believe that everything happens for a reason. I DO believe that we can FIND a lesson in our life experiences. Will we find it? Perhaps.
I don't believe that God/dess has a master plan. God/dess is of Nature-- Nature acts according to its own laws.
I don't believe in the philosophy that if it is good, then it is from God/dess, and if it is bad, it is evil/from the Devil; I don't believe in the Devil... once again, I believe in Nature, and Nature can be beautiful and it can be destructive. Nature has nothing against us; it just works according to the laws of Nature...
Excellent, very interesting question!
I am glad to hear that your daughter is doing better, Barbara. May she continue to improve and improve!
I do believe that most of what we encounter has a lesson learned for us. We'll most likely be in a similar situation at some point, and we should be able to reference the first situation to improve the second.
I don't always tie it to my faith, however.
So glad to hear your daughter continues to improve.
Ohhhhh boy. This is a toughie.
Is there a lesson that exists in everything we experience? Is it always a good one? If not, I do you reconcile it with your faith, and belief that this is what God has in store of us as individual's or as a group of people?
OK, here's my two cents' worth:
I think the lesson is not always for us. Perhaps it happened to you and yours so that the person in the bed next to your daughter would be affected in some way. Or perhaps there was a message to be sent to someone on the medical staff. Or perhaps it's a message still waiting to be delivered!
Of course it's also possible that God set the world spinning into place and has stepped back and is not involved. Perhaps he's temporarily bored with his playthings and is making another world elsewhere. Meanwhile, his administrators are doing their best just to hold it together.
As for me, I think it's the first idea, not the second.
BTW, I am extremely happy to hear the good news. I adore my children and empathise greatly with what you've been going through.
Barbara, I'm so glad to hear your daughter is getting better.
I am agnostic & a humanist. my veiw is that things just happen & our human character determines the consquences. It is up to us to find the lesson in circumstances. If you want to think that GOD (whoever he, she, is) is involved fine. I choose to believe we ultimately determine what will conspire.
'God' can only be the perfect being; in any religion. For humans that means a perfect human. 'God' would react to a situation in a perfect way. & that is what we strive to do. In the holocaust, people showed greed, prejudice, cowardice, & a bunch of other traits detrimental to humanity's progress & the consequences were devastating. Us humans must decide what's best for us.
I think that we humans, in our hearts, have the capacity to know what's best for us.
Perhaps we can learn something from each thing we experience, but sometimes all we learn is that pain is a part of life.
Glad your daughter is improving.
I've had my share. When my baby died, the news seemed to be flooded with stories of crack babies and AIDS babies with almost no chance for survival and parents who couldn't do their job even if hte babies lived.
I couldn't help but ask why...
At certain times of the year, I still ask why. And then I revert back to thast self-consoling adage "Everything happens for a reason" and "I am the product of ALL my experiences." But to be honest, I'm not sure I believe those words I say to myself.
Sometimes things just suck and you have to keep living anyway. There are more eloquent ways to phrase it, but the meaning doesn't change much.
This has turned into a very interesting, complex discussion.
Perhaps it should have been worded as a two part question?
1. Is there always a lesson that exists in everything we experience?
2. If so, what is the source of that lesson and what is do be learned, gained or determined from that experience.
Tan Lucy says, perhaps we can learn something from each experience, and pain is an outcome of some of these experiences. This is a perfect statement, that makes sense to be. Not all of our experiences are make us feel good. Whether we learn something from that or not, depends upon us, our attitude and perception of others and the world.
Whether we believe that what happens is a results of acts of God, as part of His devine plan, or a result of natural events, or a combination is another issue, which may or may not effect the lessons we learn, resulting in passion, pain, joy or happiness.
First of all I hope well recovery to your daughter, soon.
I just found your blog through "OldOldLady" and I bookmark you.
I like so much your text, it's well written and the issues so important and interesting!
Regards from Sonia. (São Paulo, Brazil)
I see frumgirl's statement right beside me. I do not agree that we have to believe it, know it or accept it.
To believe is a choice we make, to believe means we have stopped wondering. We have choosen to stop. To know it? how do you 'Know It'? only by emotions can you 'know it'. Accept it. Accept what? Gods master plan. Who is God?
The Christian God or the Hindu God or the Jewish or the muslim?
I enjoyed reading the post and all the comments. This is a subject I use to debate with gusto .. now I just read it and go on.
My biggest issue is this .. If God is who we think God is, why are there so much suffering, and injustice?
Of course my answer is always in the question asked ... So, could it be because we are experiencing life as human beings, and as such, suffering is a part of living?
I don't think life is about learning. I believe it's about experiencing living on any and all levels. If this be the case I can understand a God who is an absent landlord. Otherwise this world makes no sense to me at all.
I am so glad to hear that your daughter is doing better. That's wonderful, Barbara.
I believe that life is full of good and bad events. And I don't believe they are all necessarily for a reason. But I do believe that we can learn and grow from each event.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home